If you have ever been at Windham’s Crossroads on Christmas Eve, then you have surely enjoyed Woodrow’s famous eggnog.
This post may contain Amazon or other affiliate links. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase anything through any affiliate link, I may earn a small commission at no extra charge to you. All opinions are my own.
For as long as I can remember, my father, Woodrow Windham, would whip up a huge batch of eggnog. He would invite all his brothers, sisters, cousins, friends, and neighbors to drop in on Christmas Eve for a cup of his super nog.
Several years before he passed away, to my surprise, he called me into the kitchen to assist with the secret process. It was important to him to pass the eggnog torch to the next generation. And I was honored to learn the recipe.
Of course we are going to keep the tradition going, so I’ll be Jim’s assistant in the making of the eggnog. I’m now prepared to share this recipe with you. This recipe completely fills a large punch bowl, so I hope you have lots of friends and relatives. If you have some left over, it keeps well in the refrigerator.
Here’s what you’ll need:
- 1 dozen eggs
- 1/2 gallon whole milk
- 1 cup sugar
- 2 quarts premade eggnog (that you buy in the grocery store)
- 2 cups bourbon
- ground nutmeg
The first thing that you will do is separate your eggs into two large mixing bowls. If you have a stand mixer, you can use the bowl of the mixer for your egg whites. This is the most important step in making the eggnog. Do NOT, and I repeat, do NOT, get any of the egg yolks into the whites. It was my mother’s job to separate the eggs while listening to my father constantly saying, “Don’t get any egg yolks in the whites! Don’t get any egg yolks in the whites!” If you do get any yolks into the whites, throw it out and start over.
Set the egg whites aside. Using a hand mixer, beat the egg yolks and slowly pour in the 2 cups of bourbon. This is where my father would tell me that the bourbon would cook the eggs. Beat the egg yolks until they are a frothy, golden yellow. Go ahead and put the sugar in and beat some more until the sugar dissolves. Pour this mixture into the punch bowl and add a half gallon of whole milk and the 2 quarts of prepared eggnog. Use the hand mixer to thoroughly blend all the ingredients.
In a separate large bowl, whip your egg whites until soft peaks form. If you only have a hand mixer, be sure to thoroughly wash your beaters before this step. If any speck of yolk remains on your beaters, it will ruin your egg whites. Do yourself a favor and use a stand mixer for this process if you have one.
Now it’s time to put the finishing touches on your concoction. Using a spatula, fold in the egg whites into the other mixture. This step takes two people. While one person is folding in the egg whites, the other person is using the hand mixer to slowly blend everything together until it’s smooth and frothy. Generously sprinkle nutmeg on top.
My father always made a toast but since he is no longer with us, the patriarch of our family, my brother Woody (Woodrow Draten Windham, Jr.) does the honor.
While we’re making the eggnog, Woody usually entertains all the kids with a singalong.
Live from Windham’s Crossroads,