• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Cottage at the Crossroads

menu icon
go to homepage
  • Canning
  • Gardening
  • Recipes
  • Air Fryer
  • Desserts
  • DIY
  • Crafts
  • Holidays
  • Christmas
  • Recipe Collections
  • Fall Decor
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
  • search icon
    Homepage link
    • Canning
    • Gardening
    • Recipes
    • Air Fryer
    • Desserts
    • DIY
    • Crafts
    • Holidays
    • Christmas
    • Recipe Collections
    • Fall Decor
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
  • ×
    Home » Recipe Collections

    37 Recipes From The Great Depression for a Filling Meal

    By: Jane · Updated: 24 Aug, '23 · This post may contain affiliate links · Leave a Comment

    Sharing is caring!

    37 recipes from the great depression for a filling meal pinterest image.

    The Great Depression was a desolate era where millions of Americans struggled to make ends meet. Food was pricey and scarce during this time, so it was essential to make long-lasting meals that filled you up and didn't waste anything.

    37 recipes from the great depression for a filling meal facebook image.

    While we might not be in a Great Depression today per se, it's still imperative to save money where possible. As such, we can learn a thing or two from early 1900s culinary concoctions as they utilized cheap ingredients and made satiating meals.

    Here are 37 of these recipes which you can easily recreate today.

    Contents
    • 1. Meatloaf
    • 2. Chili
    • 3. Macaroni and Cheese
    • 4. Chipped Beef and Toast
    • 5 Peanut Butter and Pickle Sandwich
    • 6. Potato Soup
    • 7. Baked Beans
    • 8. Wacky Cake
    • 9. Creamed Chicken Over Biscuits
    • 10. Meat and Potato Patties
    • 11. Hoover Stew
    • 12. Potato Pancake
    • 13. Spam
    • 14. Dandelion Salad
    • 15. Cornbread
    • 16. Tomato Soup
    • 17. Water Pie
    • 18. Depression Bread
    • 19. Navy Bean Soup
    • 20. Bologna Casserole
    • 21. Vinegar Pie
    • 22. Goulash
    • 23. Stuffed Onions
    • 24. Rice Pudding
    • 25. Peanut Butter Bread
    • 26. "Goop"
    • 27. Mulligan Stew
    • 28. Egg Drop Soup
    • 29. Fish Chowder
    • 30. Bread Pudding
    • 31. Frozen Fruit Salad
    • 32. Porridge
    • 33. Applesauce
    • 34. Cabbage Soup
    • 35. Creamed Tuna on Toast
    • 36. Haluski
    • 37. Coffee Soup
    • Final Thoughts
    • 💬 Comments

    1. Meatloaf

    Juicy meatloaf in a white casserole.

    If you've lived in the States long enough, you've probably had meatloaf with a side of mashed potatoes and vegetables.

    While the name sounds pretty unappetizing, this seasoned loaf of meat is actually quite delicious and is highly versatile (basically, you can throw anything you have on hand inside of it).

    2. Chili

    Scrumptious chili in a mug on a plate.

    A popular dish that fed a family in the Great Depression was one that is still familiar today: chili.

    Yes, this thick, tomato-based soup was quite the hearty meal as it capitalized on beans, which were both cheap and filling. Furthermore, you could put any meat you happened to have, and it didn't matter how tough it was since you could simmer the chili for so long.

    3. Macaroni and Cheese

    Delicious macaroni and cheese in a white bowl.
    Image source: The Chunky Chef

    Yet another dish that can be made in bulk, macaroni and cheese, is a holiday staple in American cuisine. Commonly made on Thanksgiving and Christmas, this luxuriously decadent food has well surpassed its popularity in the early 1900s.

    4. Chipped Beef and Toast

    Delicious chipped beef and toast in a blue plate.
    Image source: Allrecipes

    Still served in diners across the US, chipped beef and toast are somewhat of an underrated breakfast/dinner option.

    Like every other recipe on this list, the ingredients are inexpensive, and it'll fill you up for pretty much the whole day (plus, it tastes pretty good too).

    5 Peanut Butter and Pickle Sandwich

    Delicious peanut butter and pickle sandwich.
    Image source: Cooking NY Times

    Unlike the previous entries on this list, the peanut butter and pickle sandwich SOUNDS like it came from the Great Depression.

    This is one of those "don't knock it until you try it" kinda deals. While you might think peanut butter and pickles are conflicting flavors, they work surprisingly well with each other.

    6. Potato Soup

    Delicious potato soup in white bowls.
    Image source: Sugar Spun Run

    Potatoes didn't just help Americans in their time of need. They're a world-renowned root vegetable that has allowed peasants and poor families to survive starvation at almost every age.

    Potato soup, in particular, was a clever way to stretch out the nutrient-dense nature of the potato and feed multiple people at once.

    7. Baked Beans

    Juicy baked beans on a white plate.
    Image source: The Pioneer Woman

    Eat them on toast or alone; baked beans are a sweet, tangy stew of slow-cooked beans. Despite their prominence in the "Cowboy era," baked beans were especially important from 1920 on because they were widely available.

    Today, you can find them in cans on the shelves of every supermarket, but they're even more delicious when you make them from scratch.

    8. Wacky Cake

    A piece of wacky cake on a white plate.
    Image source: Allrecipes

    The wacky cake might scare you, knowing it came from the Great Depression, but it's just chocolate cake without milk or eggs.

    Despite its shortcomings, it still somehow manages to be moist and delicious.

    9. Creamed Chicken Over Biscuits

    Delicious creamed chicken over biscuits on a gray plate with a fork.
    Image source: Delicious Little Bites

    The name of this recipe might make you think of Southern comfort food, but it comes from an era that was anything but comfortable.

    Creamy, savory, and filling, this meal will make you feel sluggish yet satisfied when finished.

    10. Meat and Potato Patties

    Meat and potato patties with brussels sprouts on a white plate.
    Image source: Taste Of Home

    Meat was obviously hard to come by during the Depression, so mixing it in with other foods was an absolute must. Combining ground beef with potatoes to create patties was a prime example of how you could stretch out a tiny bit of meat to make a much larger meal.

    11. Hoover Stew

    Hoover stew i na pot.
    Image source: The Frugal Navy Wife

    To your dismay, Hoover Stew isn't really a stew.

    It's more of a macaroni salad where hot dogs are the "stars" of the show. That said, it isn't all that bad and is a cheap meal to make when you don't feel like cooking.

    12. Potato Pancake

    Crispy potato pancakes on a baking grid.
    Image source: Allrecipes

    People even stretched out the humble potato by adding copious amounts of flour and frying them to a shining golden brown.

    Of course, potato pancakes have a long history, which predates the Great Depression by many centuries.

    13. Spam

    Spam canned meat in a skillet.
    Image source: The Heirloom Pantry

    Invented towards the end of the Great Depression in 1937, Spam was a form of canned meat that used an unpopular cut of meat, the pork shoulder.

    After America was snapped out of its Depression upon entering WWII, Spam's legacy would persist as wartime food and eventually become a worldwide phenomenon.

    14. Dandelion Salad

    Healthy dandelion salad on a white plate.
    Image source: Allrecipes

    While you might have trouble finding the ingredients for this one today, Dandelion salad was all too common during the Depression.

    Still, this weed salad topped with tomatoes and other veg isn't all that bad - especially when you add a little dressing.

    15. Cornbread

    Pieces of scrumptious cornbread on a white plate.
    Image source: Bless This Mess Please

    Cornbread is eaten widely today and is a beloved staple of the South, but did you know that many relied on it in the early 1900s?

    As a matter of fact, it was initially made with only three ingredients: yeast, cornmeal, and water.

    16. Tomato Soup

    Healthy tomato soup in a white bowl.
    Image source: Cooking NY Times

    You might remember eating tomato soup as a child with a side of grilled cheese. Well, so do many people who lived through the Great Depression, although they probably didn't have the sandwich to go along with it.

    17. Water Pie

    Delicous water pie on a wooden tray.
    Image source: Southern Plate

    Water pie made sort of a comeback in 2020 with the coming of the Corona pandemic and is surprisingly better tasting than you'd expect.

    Made primarily with water, sugar, and flour, water pie is a creamy treat that's cheap to make (like, REALLY cheap) and serves its purpose as a tasty dessert.

    18. Depression Bread

    Loaf of depression bread on a wooden table.
    Image source: Busy Mommy Media

    With limited access to eggs, depression bread skipped the expensive stuff and was made solely with water, flour, and yeast.

    It's kind of like the water pipe in the way that it uses bare-bones ingredients to create an actual meal.

    19. Navy Bean Soup

    Delicious navy bean soup in a bowl.
    Image source: The Kitchn

    While most of the people who made navy bean soup during the Depression probably used hot dogs, you have the luxury of putting ham in yours.

    Classy right?

    20. Bologna Casserole

    A piece of bologna casserole on a white tray.
    Image source: Allrecipes

    You're probably aware that casseroles were popular in the 1900s, but the depressed people of the Depression took their recipes to a new level by putting bologna in them.

    And you know what? It's not as bad as you think. Kids seem to love it, and adults are always surprised when they realize how edible it is.

    21. Vinegar Pie

    A piece of vinegar pie on a plate with a fork.
    Image source: Pastry Chef Online

    Vinegar pie sounds worse than water pie, but don't let its deceptive name fool you. Think of it like a lemon pie, which is slightly acidic, but calmed enough by the sweetness of sugar.

    We're not saying you HAVE to try it, but we're just saying; you probably already have the ingredients for this one.

    22. Goulash

    Delicious goulash in a white bowl.
    Image source: I Wash You Dry

    Goulash was a relatively popular dish of the Depression, given that it provided all the protein and carbs necessary to get a working man through the week.

    Even today, it's an affordable dinner that tastes great and is budget-friendly.

    23. Stuffed Onions

    Delicious stuffed onions on a metal tray.
    Image source: Cooking NY Times

    Onions stuffed with rice are as impoverished as you could get. At least, that's what a person from a hundred years ago would tell you.

    The funny part is many high-end restaurants are willing to put this item on their menus simply because it hails from French cuisine.

    24. Rice Pudding

    Delicious rice pudding in a blue bowl.
    Image source: Spicy Southern Kitchen

    Some accounts trace the origins of rice pudding back to 8000 BCE. Well, thousands of years later, people were still finding good use for this culinary invention as it was a widely consumed dessert during the Depression era.

    25. Peanut Butter Bread

    Delicious peanut butter bread drizzled with honey.
    Image source: Sprinkle Bakes

    Two extremely popular ingredients in the Depression were peanut butter and bread. This dish combines them and creates a slightly sweet, nutty bread ideal for making PB&J.

    It also tastes pretty good on its own and is ideal for those rushed mornings when you don't have time to make a proper breakfast.

    26. "Goop"

    Delicious goop dish on a white plate.
    Image source: 12 Tomatoes

    Goop was a slang name for a one-pot dish consisting of, well, whatever one had on hand. Usually, this was ground meat, rice, noodles, and whatever vegetables were available. Luckily, it tastes better than the name sounds.

    27. Mulligan Stew

    Healthy mulligan stew in a white bowl.
    Image source: Small Town Woman

    Mulligan stew, aka hobo stew, was a stew said to have been created by camps of hobos in the early 1900s.

    It consisted of whatever the people in homeless camps could scrounge up, so recipes for this dish vary widely.

    28. Egg Drop Soup

    Delicious egg drop soup in a small bowl.
    Image source: The Woks Of Life

    Since eggs were so hard to get, making them into bigger meals was vital. One such dish that did this was egg drop soup, which came from the Asian-American subculture and rose to fame during the Depression.

    Given that egg prices are high right now, this soup might see another surge in popularity soon.

    29. Fish Chowder

    Healthy fish chowder in a white bowl.
    Image source: Simply Recipes

    Prevalent in coastal regions, fish chowder made locally sourced seafood into a deliciously creamy soup. As you may have guessed by now, soups and stews were essential during the Great Depression.

    30. Bread Pudding

    Scrumptious bread pudding in a bowl.
    Image source: Cooking NY Times

    Like rice pudding, bread pudding makes carby food into a sweet dessert. And you know what? It's a fantastic dessert you should try regardless of whether or not you're watching your funds.

    31. Frozen Fruit Salad

    A piece of frozen fruit salad on a white plate.
    Image source: Cooking With Carlee

    Back then, it was a way to quickly utilize frozen and canned fruits to avoid scurvy.

    Nowadays, it's a delicious summer treat that'll cool you down without breaking the bank.

    32. Porridge

    Delicious porridge in a gray bowl.
    Image source: BBC Good Food

    You probably expected this one, but it gets mentioned anyway, "just cuz."

    And if you thought rice pudding was the oldest dish on this list, you'd be wrong. Sources indicate that porridge was there in the beginnings of civilized mankind, so yeah. It was and always has been, a staple depression food.

    33. Applesauce

    Delicious applesauce in a glass cup with cinnamon stick.
    Image source: Allrecipes

    That sweet, appley mush you ate as a child? Yeah, that was depression food.

    Applesauce was a common food item found in 1900s pantries since it could be stored for long periods and was simple to make.

    34. Cabbage Soup

    Delicious cabbage soup in a pot and two white bowls.
    Image source: Love And Lemons

    Surprise, surprise, they made cabbage into a delicious soup. The benefit here is that you didn't have to decide between soup or salad when you went out to eat.

    That was a joke. No one could afford to eat out during that time.

    35. Creamed Tuna on Toast

    Deliicous creamed tuna on toast on a colorful plate.
    Image source: Food

    Based on chipped beef, creamed tuna was a slightly more affordable option because it came in cans.

    Think of it like a tuna salad variety, and you have a tasty lunch that won't break the bank.

    36. Haluski

    Healthy haluski dish on a plate.
    Image source: A Family Feast

    It came from the Slavic region and translated quite well into the Depression since the main ingredients were cabbage and noodles. Meat could be added accordingly, and frying up this dish could feed a family quite effectively in the most desperate of times.

    37. Coffee Soup

    Delicious coffee soup in a gray bowl with a plastic spoon.
    Image source: Food

    Ending off our list is an excellent retro dish you know and love as coffee soup.

    Okay, you probably don't know or love this soup, but it's pretty decent. It's a sweet soup that makes a great breakfast when you can't afford anything other than coffee, buttermilk, bread, and sugar.

    When you think about it, cereal is a soup, too, so it's not THAT weird.

    Final Thoughts

    Thus concludes our list of Great Depression foods that make a filling meal. Some recipes mentioned may be familiar to you, while others… may not be.

    Still, regardless of how "innovative" these dishes are, we can guarantee they're not as bad as they sound and are entirely budget-friendly. Don't be scared! Give them a try!

    What's your favorite struggle meal you make when you're on a budget? Tell us in a comment down below!

    More Recipe Collections

    • Four scrumptious dishes witl old bay.
      27 Recipes With Old Bay for a Touch of Spice
    • Four delicious canned peach dishes.
      21 Canned Peach Recipes for Sweet Treats
    • Four delicious meals with canned peas.
      25 Canned Pea Recipes That Are Quick And Easy
    • Four scrumptious desserts that start with s.
      17 Desserts That Start With S for a Sweet Treat

    Sharing is caring!

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

    No Comments

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Primary Sidebar

    Jane @ Cottage at the Crossroads

    We're Jane and Leo!

    Thanks for stopping by! We're renovating and preserving our family's 100 year old home place where we garden, complete a few DIY projects, and do some cooking. Please leave us a comment so that we'll know that you were here.

    about →

    Reader Favorites

    • A garden journal with dividers and tabs
      How to Set Up a Garden Journal
    • Wooden garden obelisks
      DIY Wooden Garden Obelisk
    • Sweet cucumber relish - featured
      Sweet Cucumber Relish
    • Growing cucumbers in raised beds
      Growing Cucumbers in Raised Beds

    Gardening How-tos

    • Best way to remove weeds from large area
      Best Ways To Remove Weeds From a Large Area
    • Potting mix vs. Potting soil
      Potting Mix vs. Potting Soil
    • How to dry and store fresh garden herbs
      How To Dry Herbs
    • 1
      Instant Pot Canning Basics
    • Cookbook Reviews (2)
    • DIY (161)
      • Crafts (75)
      • Home Decor (18)
      • Outdoor Projects (34)
      • Painted Furniture (29)
      • Tablescapes (23)
    • End of Year Review (8)
    • Favorites (7)
    • Gardening (108)
      • Container Gardening (22)
      • Flowers (20)
      • Gardening How To (30)
      • Herbs (4)
      • Structures (20)
      • Vegetables (13)
    • General (18)
    • Holidays (160)
      • Christmas (71)
      • Easter (27)
      • Halloween (3)
      • Independence Day (7)
      • Thanksgiving (10)
      • Valentine's Day (19)
    • Our Cottage (10)
    • Printables (10)
    • Recipe Collections (71)
    • Recipes (260)
      • Air Fryer (81)
      • Appetizers (29)
      • Beverages (8)
      • Canning (33)
      • Desserts (42)
      • Main Dishes (25)
      • Salads (18)
      • Sides (41)
      • Soups (17)
    • Renovations (7)
    • RVing (1)
    • Seasonal (90)
      • Fall Decor (42)
      • Spring Decor (32)
      • Summer Decor (16)

    Growing Vegetables

    • Fall vegetable garden | cottage at the crossroads
      Our Fall Vegetable Garden
    • Garden and yard may 2013 132
      Evolution of a Garden
    • Our best tomato plants are celebrities
      How to Grow Your Own Tomatoes
    • Growing lettuce in containers
      Growing Lettuce in Containers

    Footer

    As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

    © 2021 Cottage at the Crossroads · All Rights Reserved

    Contact Us · Privacy

    2 shares