We have an abundance of cucumbers growing in our garden right now, so I made some bread and butter pickles yesterday. I followed the same recipe that I used last year because everyone that tasted them, loved them.
Now I have to admit that I’m no expert on canning because I’ve only been doing it for three years. But I’m feeling more comfortable at doing it and recommending recipes for you. For this recipe, I used a water bath to process the pickles because I like to have them on hand all year long. But if you don’t want to can or don’t have the equipment, there are plenty of recipes online for some that you don’t have to process. The only negative is that they will only last in your refrigerator for a few weeks.
This post may contain Amazon or other affiliate links. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase anything through any affiliate link, I may earn a small commission at no extra charge to you. All opinions are my own.
But bread and butter pickles are worth making, either way you decide to make them. Homemade ones tastes soooo much better than the ones you buy in the store. They have the perfect balance between sweet and tangy.
So I was wondering why they are called bread and butter pickles. Supposedly they got their name because during the Great Depression, they were a cheap staple in households. So people used them in sandwiches of bread and butter because that’s all they could afford. I’ve never eaten them that way, but I’ll just have to give it a try.
To make these pickles, you will need about 10 cups of sliced and trimmed pickling cucumbers. Make the slices about 1/4 inch thick. Also, thinly slice 4 medium sized onions. I used Vidalia onions.
You will need 1/2 cup canning or pickling salt. Do not use regular salt because it has additives that make your pickle solution cloudy.
Sprinkle the salt onto your cucumbers and onions.
Add enough cool water to cover them and let them stand at room temperature for 2 hours.
Place them in a colander, rinse with cool running water, and drain thoroughly. Pull out all your canning gear and prepare your jars because you are ready to make your pickles!
First, place 3 cups of white vinegar in a large stainless steel pot. I’ve read to check the label of your vinegar to make sure the acidity level is 5%. Most of the labels I’ve checked lately say 5%.
Add 2 cups granulated sugar, 2 tablespoons mustard seeds, 1 teaspoon each of celery seeds and turmeric and heat to a boil. Stir to dissolve the sugar.
Stir in your vegetables and return to a boil.
Ladle the vegetables into hot, sterilized jars. I usually fill mine about half full, then I use a thin spatula to push the vegetables down further into the jar.
This is called packing the jar. If you don’t do this, you will have pickles swimming in liquid! Believe me, I learned from experience!
Finish filling the jar and then pour more of the pickling liquid over the vegetables, remove any air bubbles with the spatula, leave 1/2 inch headspace, and wipe the rim. Center a warm lid on the jar and screw on a band.
Process the jars for 10 minutes. Remove the lid and wait 5 minutes before removing the jars.
Place the jars on a thick towel and let them cool overnight.
You are going to be a hit at any barbeque that you attend this summer if you bring these pickles! Click HERE if you’d like a printable version of this recipe.
I thought I’d show your our cucumber plants. We plant them along the fence and train them to grow up the fence.
And this isn’t all of them. They are planted along another side, too.
Do you think I have more pickle making in my future?
*Update concerning the origin of the term “bread and butter pickles”: Two readers have pointed out that a trademark was registered in 1923 by Omar and Cora Fanning from Illinois and was used on their logo. Apparently the recipe has existed for much longer than that because the Fannings used an old family recipe. So the origin of the term is still debatable. I think a better idea is to just make some pickles and enjoy them!
I’m joining:
Metamorphosis [email protected] Naps on the Porch
Cowgirl [email protected]Cedar Hill Ranch
Cozy Home [email protected]Cozy Home Scenes
Uncommonly [email protected]Uncommon Designs
Dawn says
I am not going to go down to your level. It would have been better if you would have pointed out her mistake and added the correct information.
Jane Windham says
You’re right.
DIGI says
“Supposedly they got their name because during the Great Depression”
What a load of shit.
Nice thesis on how your kids went to college, but you have committed to the ultimate sin of online recipes.if you did any research, you would know they are called that because its a coined phrase “my bread and butter” and the product was patented in the 1920’s with them in the name. because they were considered a cheap staple in the household. when something is your ‘bread and butter’ it is your everyday common house hold necessities and was named as such by Mr and Mrs Fanning which sold budget pickles, typically traded for other essentials before they were a business.
Jane Windham says
Goodness! You certainly have strong opinions on how bread ‘n butter pickles got their name!
Lucie Canamore says
It’s not an opinion, it’s fact! When you are blogging, you have a certain responsibility to your readers to gice facts. You, ma’am, just outright lied about how bread and butter pickles got their name, and people believe you. You aren’t giving credit to the real people, Omar and Cora Fanning from Streator, IL, that got a trademark on the name in 1923. Which,, by the way, was before the depression, which started at the end of 1939. Cora named them that because she would trade these pickles for bread and butter. Maybe do some fact checking from now on so you don’t spread lies. Your stories may be homey and kitschy, but the truth is better!! I am very disappointed that people like you think it’s ok to make up history.
Jane Windham says
When I originally published this recipe in 2012, there was little information about the origin of the term “bread and butter pickle.”
Gary says
Yeah, you didn’t have to be coarse. While you’re at it, Google Thumper’s Father.
As for the explanation of bread and butter, I was just wondering how do you make a sandwich without bread, and with just pickles???? LOL
Connie says
I want to try the the bread and butter pickles.
Please explain what you mean, by processing for 10 minutes, then you remove the lid………
At what point do you put the lid and band back on the jar?
I am confused…..don’t understand this process.
Thank you
Jane Windham says
Process the pickles in the canning pot for 10 minutes, turn off the heat, and remove the lid of the canning pot. Let the jars sit in the water for about 5 minutes before removing them from the pot.
Justine Turner says
Hi, i made your relish recipe today and thank you, it is devine. I had lost my recipe and yours was the closest to mine. Question about bread and butter pickles. I have a family member that has a heart pump and cannot consume any zero salt. What would happen if i leave the salt step out?
Jane Windham says
Thanks Justine! I always thought that the salt in pickle recipes provided the crunch so I googled your question. I’m sending you a link to a salt free dill pickle recipe that I found. I was unable to find a salt free version of bread and butter pickles but it may be worth making a very small batch to taste test.
Gardner says
Is your name Jane? I just love you. I am so excited about trying to can this stuff. I’m making Christmas baskets of my canning adventures. Do you have any soup idea??
Thanks for your help! Gardner Riel
rose says
i love bread and butter pickles
Miss Kitty says
Hi Jane! I have never canned anything in my life but I might have to try after seeing your great recipe. I didn’t know that the homemade pickles were better than “store bought”.
Bonnie and Trish @ uncommon says
Love these! Remind me of many summer spent in the garden and canning!! Featured them tonight! stop by and grab a button! 🙂
Ann says
I’d say you are getting to be quite the expert on canning. I am impressed! I adore any kind of pickles and bread & butters are one of my favorites. I have to admit I can’t imagine eating a bread and pickle sandwich though. Saw your tomato sauce today on FB. You are a canning machine! Have a lovely Sunday and take it easy…
Helen says
Jane, they look too pretty to eat. Y’all are multi-talented. Thanks for following me on Twitter.
Helen
debbie says
These bring back so many memories for me. My gramps LOVED bread and butter pickles. I do too actually. These look yummy!
Dolly Sarrio says
Jane I am going to make these you make it seem so simple. I have never made them ashamed to say but have always wanted to. Thanks for the recipe!
Folks do you see her pics of her garden? They are great pics but her garden is a showplace just beautiful!
Thanks Jane.
Mary says
Jane~ You are so industrious with your canning~ I have to admit I’m intimidated by the canning process! It looks like you’re going to have a bumper crop of cukes 🙂
Shannon @ Cozy Home Scenes says
I know I dropped by the other day, but I wanted to stop by again to thank you for visiting me at Your Cozy Home Party. I always love seeing your posts, so I hope you’ll come by next week. Have a great Tuesday.
Linda says
Yumm! I might think about making some of these babies. I used to eat them when I was younger. Thanks for sharing this recipe. I think you will be making more pickles in the future.
Ginger says
You and Leo are amazing. I love your garden and yes there will be a lot more pickles and salads.
Have a great week. Ginger
[email protected] Designs says
I remember my mom and dad making those wonderful pickles….brings back so many memories…They look so wonderful!…I am glad that so are enjoying the harvest of your gardens!
Keeping it Cozy says
Delicious, I look forward to trying this! (We are still eating pickles from last summer.) I just picked our first cucumber yesterday…
Jean Windham says
I can’t wait to taste the new pickles. I looks as though you have really been busy with all the canning. I am sure there will be many to enjoy them.
Barbara F. says
I want to make some pickles, too, Jane. I made my jam, following the recipe, I only got one jar and maybe a third of another! Next time I will double the recipe. I’ll post it so we can all laugh. But it did taste good. xo
Diane says
Now this is what I’ve been waiting for! Thanks Jane!
Shannon @ Cozy Home Scenes says
My mom used to do a lot of canning when I was young. An older lady taught her how since we had such a huge garden and 2 greenhouses. We don’t do much gardening now except for a little in containers, but those are days we miss very much. Hope you enjoy your pickles!
Gina says
I bet these are so wonderfully delicious! You are making me wish I had a garden.